Meniscus Transplant
What is a Meniscal Transplant?
A meniscal transplant is a complex and highly specialized surgical procedure designed for patients who have previously undergone a complete meniscectomy and are experiencing symptoms that impact their daily life. These individuals often face a higher risk of developing osteoarthritis due to the absence of the meniscus, which serves as a cushion between the knee joint’s bones. The primary goal of a meniscal transplant is to restore the knee’s function and structure by implanting a donor meniscus. This helps improve shock absorption and promotes better alignment between the bones, thereby protecting joint health and enhancing mobility.
Meniscal transplants are generally recommended for younger, active patients who have undergone a total meniscectomy and continue to experience pain, limited mobility, or mechanical issues that hinder their quality of life. Before considering surgery, candidates must have tried non-operative treatments without sufficient improvement. Additionally, patients should have minimal cartilage damage, as severe joint degeneration or extensive cartilage loss can make the procedure less effective or technically challenging. The ideal candidate is someone with a well-preserved joint space, minimal arthritis, and a strong commitment to postoperative rehabilitation.
However, it is crucial to be aware of certain limitations and risks. Similar to other organ transplants, a meniscal transplant carries potential immunologic risks, including the body’s rejection of the graft. There is also a minimal risk of disease transmission from the donor tissue and limited donor availability, which can affect the timing of the surgery.
Once a patient is deemed a suitable candidate, the next step involves thorough preoperative imaging to ensure that the donor meniscus is accurately sized for the patient’s knee. When a size-matched and immunologically compatible graft becomes available, surgery is scheduled.
During the procedure, Dr. Cinque will make an incision along the patellar tendon to access the knee joint. The donor meniscus, referred to as an allograft, is then inserted using techniques such as the bone plug method or bone fixation method. Both techniques are effective, and current research does not show a significant advantage of one over the other. The chosen method will depend on the specific requirements of the patient’s knee and the surgeon’s expertise.
The procedure aims to secure the meniscal graft in a way that ensures optimal integration with the surrounding tissue. This step is critical for the long-term success of the surgery, as improper placement or attachment can lead to complications and decreased efficacy.
Rehabilitation following a meniscal transplant is rigorous and requires strict adherence to maximize the chances of a successful outcome. Among all types of meniscal surgeries, the rehabilitation process for a meniscal transplant is the most demanding.
For the first six weeks post-surgery, patients must wear a knee immobilizer and remain non-weight bearing, using crutches to prevent any undue pressure on the transplanted meniscus. This period is crucial for allowing the graft to integrate securely with the surrounding knee structures. During weeks six to eight, patients can gradually begin partial weight-bearing and work towards full weight-bearing as the knee gains stability. Range of motion exercises remain limited until the eight-week mark to protect the newly integrated tissue.
By 12 weeks, patients can start more functional activities, such as lunges and light strengthening exercises, under the guidance of a physical therapist. The complete rehabilitation process may extend over several months, with the ultimate goal of returning to full, unrestricted activity. Patience and dedication during this phase are essential for a successful recovery and to minimize the risk of graft failure.
Meniscal transplants offer several advantages, including reduced knee pain, improved joint function, and the potential delay of osteoarthritis progression. For many active patients, the procedure can be life-changing, enabling them to return to sports and activities they enjoy. However, it’s essential to have realistic expectations. While a meniscal transplant can significantly improve quality of life, it is not a cure for arthritis and cannot fully restore a knee to its pre-injury state.
Patients considering this surgery must also understand the importance of adhering to postoperative protocols. Failure to follow rehabilitation guidelines can compromise the surgical outcome and may lead to complications or graft failure.
A meniscal transplant is a highly specialized procedure that provides hope for those who have undergone a total meniscectomy and continue to struggle with pain and limited knee function. Under the expertise of surgeons like Dr. Cinque, this procedure aims to restore knee stability and function, delaying or preventing the onset of arthritis. Comprehensive preoperative assessment, a carefully executed surgical plan, and a strict postoperative rehabilitation regimen are crucial for achieving the best outcomes. If you are considering a meniscal transplant, consult with Dr. Cinque to understand whether it aligns with your health goals and lifestyle needs.
Orthopedic surgeon Dr. Mark Cinque is a sports medicine surgeon in San Diego, California who specializes in the treatment of complex knee injuries. He has spent time training at The Steadman Clinic and Stanford Orthopaedic Surgery. He has published over 100 peer-reviewed manuscripts and has presented research internationally. He uses minimally invasive arthroscopic procedures to preserve the natural joint and reduce recovery time to accelerate his patients’ return to the activities they love.
At a Glance
Mark Cinque, MD
- Board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon
- Orthopedic Residency: Stanford University, Fellowship: The Steadman Clinic
- Authored over 100 peer-reviewed publications
- Learn more
